GINIEUIEUNICEF Child and Young Adult Soldiers

Global Perspectives 

Human Profile Cases: Who Are Child & Young Adult Soldiers? 



source: CCFD/CIRIC - Nicaragua, 1979

 
To view information about a particular topic, click on the appropriate heading below.

Common Profile of Child and Young Adult Soldiers
Typical Recruitment Practices
Typical Living Conditions
Individual Stories and Case Examples


Home

source: UNICEF/Said Elatab Lebanon, 1984




Common Profile of Child and Young Adult Soldiers

The number of youth soldiers fighting in conflicts around the world currently is estimated at  nearly  500,000. Child and young adult soldiers can range in age from 6 to 18 and can  be male or female.  Most child soldiers under 15 are fighting for non-governmental military groups.  Government forces tend to engage exclusively male recruits, while opposition forces might employ males and females of all ages.  Women and girls often provide support services for military groups, such as secretarial, musical, cooking, cleaning, health care, and sexual services.  However females are more likely to also serve as soldiers in armed opposition groups.  This phenomenon may be even more common in countries where women have been held back from participation in normal society.

Regardless of age, gender, or how they are recruited, child soldiers disproportionately come from the poor and marginalized segments of society, isolated rural areas,  the conflict zones themselves, and from disrupted or non-existent family backgrounds.  A uniquely disadvantaged sub-group are the inhabitants of refugee camps or internally displaced persons.  Displaced persons often regroup themselves by religion or ethnicity making it easy for religious or ethnicity based armed groups to recruit.  Recruiters target those groups who are the least able to resist, which often means the most disenfranchised groups.  In some cases where age limits are respected, if the recruit can produce documentation of age, he or she can be exempted from service, however, forced recruits are rarely able to do so unless the family can trace their whereabouts.  Recruits are often school dropouts or members of street gangs.  The flip side is that these same groups who are often the victims of  forced recruiting have the most social and economic incentives to volunteer.  Lack of education is the primary hallmark of the youth volunteer and military service is seen as an escape from the boredom of  formal education.  In some cases, though, volunteers are attracted with promises of educational opportunities or overseas travel.  Lack of education is even more characteristic of volunteers than of forced recruits. 

Click here 
to view special BBC Online Report on Youth Soldiers 
In areas plagued by conflict for many years, the youth will usually be among the poor and most deprived members of society most easily subjected to recruitment.   Also, an unusually high proportion of households will have youth as the main income earners, which contributes to the poverty level.  Poverty is important but it is not the only problem for families in conflict zones.  From the point of view of the government armed forces, youth in conflict zones are most prone to recruitment by armed opposition groups.  Therefore if armed groups are actively practicing forced recruiting, the government can require that a particular area provide an equal number of recruits to its own forces.  Thus youth from the same villages can end up fighting one another.

Also, the incentives to volunteer can be even stronger in conflict zones, especially when the conflict and participation in it is viewed as a normal part of life.  For example, sometimes family members live in armed camps with their soldier head of household and so it is viewed as normal for the children to join the conflict too.  Victims of forced resettlements in conflict zones are also especially prone to seeking membership in armed opposition groups.  The recruitment of youth also increases (targeting younger and younger children) in conflict zones due to a competition for manpower, which is always decreasing due to deaths resulting from the conflict.  Attempts by governments to counteract recruitment often results in increased volunteering, often due to harassment or a feeling of inevitability of eventual participation.  There is also a perception that living conditions are better in armed opposition groups than in government forces.  Also, sometimes government forces or armed groups pick up children and youth in conflict zones for humanitarian reasons, and they end up fighting as soldiers.

Perhaps the most at-risk group is children and youth separated from their families for whatever reason.  Conflict zones contain a high proportion of such youth.   Youth whose fathers have been recruited, detained or killed, illegitimate children, children of single parent families in general, are more prone than their peers to become child soldiers.  Unaccompanied children are easier targets and often have no one to advocate for them in any way.  Also, families often provide a solid set of anti-war values and often do whatever it takes to protect their children from the conflict, including pressuring them not to participate.  Children without families obviously do not benefit from this sort of protection.  Youth in this predicament may also volunteer because they are in search of a replacement family unit, which may be provided on some level by the armed group.

Back To Top




Typical Recruitment Practices


 source: UNICEF/Sierra Leone, 1997

There are three basic forms of recruitment described in this section: conscription, forced or induced recruitment, and voluntary recruitment. 

Click here 
for Amnesty International stories of 
youth soldier recruitment
Conscription is the legal obligation of citizens in specified categories to serve in the military.  In some countries conscription of under 18s is legal, however in most countries, compulsory service is required of males (and sometimes females) 18 or over.  There are few, if any, cases in which persons may be exempt or able to perform alternative service  for conscientous objections.  Conscription systems are often flawed and the integrity of the system can be dependent on birth and identity records which are often poor or non-existent.  In some cases, in the absence of records, youths are forced to state that they are 18 in order to conform to the presiding law.  Also, sometimes recruits enlist before the official age as a matter of convenience.  Some conscription systems rely on local recruiters who must bring in a quota of recruits of the proper age.  Sometimes when they cannot make quota they will enlist underage recruits.  Such systems often target disenfranchised sections of  the community and are especially prone to corruption and there is often little difference between this and forced recruitment.

Forced recruitment is often a response to an immediate shortfall of manpower, either because a conflict or an opposition group is unpopular or because of a high rate of migratory labor.  But in some countries there is a long standing tradition of this practice.  Certain ethnic, racial, religious, and indigenous groups are often targeted by the government because they are perceived as a threat for their potential to join opposition groups.  The most common form of forced recruitment is called press ganging.  Press ganging (known as afesa in Amharic) is when an armed militia group or police roam the streets and public gathering places, including school gates, to round up individuals they come across.  Another method is to surround and area and force every man and boy to sit or stand together while eligible recruits are selected and taken away.  In rural areas, armed groups or government militia will enter a village killing people, raping women, kidnapping children, burning and looting homes.  Anyone resisting or not escaping is killed and youth are the least able to defend themselves.  Forced recruitment may also be accomplished through intimidation to make it appear voluntary.  A government or opposition armed group might enter a village calling for volunteers.  Villagers often then report the disappearance of "volunteers" as kidnappings to avoid government retribution for participating in armed opposition groups.  Finally, some governments and opposition groups use educational establishments and orphanages as military training grounds.

Voluntary recruitment is when a youth or the family of the youth makes a conscious choice to volunteer for armed service.  There are few, if any, known instances of a military group denying participation to underage volunteers.  There can be many cultural, economic, social, ideological, and security reasons for volunteering.  In some cases, participating in war is glorified by the culture or held up as a sign of masculinity..  Some youth may be persuaded to join by their families to keep them off the streets or because they believe that military discipline is positive for the child.  Many illiterate youth believe they will earn prestige or power through military service.  Some youth may also be influenced by peer pressure or motivated by a cultural tradition of blood revenge or an obligation to replace a relative who has been killed in action.  In other cases, volunteering can occur out of a genuine belief in the cause of the conflict.  As mentioned above, youth may also volunteer because they are in search of a substitute family unit, stability, or strong role models or because they are looking for economic security or to satisfy a need for food and shelter.  Even where youth regret their decision to volunteer, they often find it impossible to leave an armed group safely.  For example, it is not only hard to leave the Sri Lankan LTTE, but it is also nearly impossible for any civilian to leave the northern zone.  Even if deserters can make it to the south, they risk being identified and detained by the police, while their family is subject to harassment and threats in the north.  Soldiers who merely express a desire to leave are subject to public beatings.  The punishment for requesting permission to quit, for example, involves being sent to dig bunkers in areas under heavy shelling, or three to four months of hard labor. 

Click here
to view Human Rights Watch reports 
on the use of youth soldiers in
Colombia, Democratic Republic of Congo, 
Sierra Leone, Lebanon, and Uganda
Back To Top




Typical Living Conditions

Interviews with former youth soldiers from government forces reveal that they are often treated the same as adult soldiers regardless of their age.  Unfortunately the treatment of government recruits of all ages is often poor and inhuman.  Government recruits often must endure brutal hazings to break down their resistance and instill fear, which can result in death, suicide, physical and emotional injury.  They endure personal physical and verbal assaults as well as training designed to sensitize them to killing.  For example, they practice cutting the throats of animals and drinking the blood.  Also, they live in an unhealthy environment that might include drug use, drinking, and prostitution.  Even though all the soldiers experience such treatment, it can be particularly difficult for children to endure.   In some cases, youth soldiers receive harsher treatment and are assigned to the lowest of the military ranks.  Hence they are given poor medical care and inadequate food rations, while their young bodies are the least able to withstand such conditions.  Some governments which legally recruit under 18s may have special policies related to them, such as less exposure to active service, the provision of recreational  facilities, or monitoring by adult support staff.

Treatment of youth soldiers  in armed opposition groups is often equally bad.   Young soldiers who cannot keep up are often killed in order to ensure their silence.  Children are often used as executioners and, in some cases, forced to participate in ritual cannibalism.  These acts might include members of the child's own family.  There is some evidence of drug and alcohol use and sexual abuse, although this is not universal. 

Click here
to view a report about youth learning to commit atrocities 
by Elisabeth Janz-Meyer Rieckh
However, in armed opposition groups where all recruits are treated well, so are the child soldiers.  This tends to be the case in ethnic-community conflicts and in conflicts where entire families are involved in the opposition group.  There do exist some opposition groups that endeavor to give special consideration to the needs of youth soldiers, including annual physical and emotional evaluations, time for play and special food or lodging conditions.  When there is not much fighting, youth soldiers in armed opposition groups might even be provided with some basic education, although such education can be tantamount to political indoctrination.

In armed opposition groups children are typically used in support capacities at the beginning of their service, rather than combat.  However, their work is often no less dangerous.  Due to their size and agility, children can also be used as look outs, spies, messengers, and porters, eventually engaging in combat when they grow older.  The use of children in this manner endangers all children in a conflict zone, as they are all subject to suspicion.  There have been reports of governments systematically killing children judged to have been indoctrinated by rebel forces.  Such action raises serious questions about government compliance with human rights conventions.  According to the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 37, under 18s should not be executed for alleged criminal acts and are entitled to the right of due process.  Adolescents are also used frequently for suicide missions, such as scouting mine fields, and other hazardous assignments.  In full scale combat, youth soldiers become casualties easily due to lack of experience, training, and endurance. 

Click here 
to read about the experiences of child soldiers 
in their own words
In most cases, children receive the same training and health care as other soldiers.  During heavy fighting the wounded are often left on the battlefield.  The most common injuries endured by youth soldiers were bullet and shrapnel wounds, loss of hearing, loss of limbs, and blindness. When captured, child soldiers of both sexes are often treated the same as adults, that is, treated as criminals or terrorists, and subjected to abusive interrogation procedures, torture, and rape.   Some government and armed opposition groups instead retrain captured youth soldiers.  However spies are usually killed brutally.  Even the mere suspicion of participation is enough to subject child prisoners to punishment and interrogation.  Often there is little or no explanation provided to families or advocates regarding the detention of youth soldiers.  Although special  protection and facilities for children is required by the Convention on the Rights of the Child (articles 37 and 40) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and other instruments, such facilities are usually inadequate or non-existent.  National laws should at least provide the minimum requirements specified in the Geneva Conventions Article 3, and the CRC articles cited above, and juvenile justice standards endorsed by the UN.  Due to long delays in the justice system, children are often deprived of basic needs care in captivity and likely to die in such conditions before they can receive proper care.  NGOs and other assistance organizations can work to improve these conditions.

Back To Top


Selected information summarized from the following sources:
Brett, R.  & McCallin, M.  (1996).  Children:  The invisible soldiers.  Stockholm: Rädda Barnen.
Goodwin-Gill, G. & Cohn, I. (1994).  Child soldiers:  The role of children in armed conflicts.  Oxford:  Clarendon Press.
International Save the Children Alliance (1998).  Stop Using Child Soldiers!  London:  Author.
 
 
Contact us